Two-tone tart

/5

PRESENTATION

A two-tone tart is the kind of dessert that just catches your eye, really, with its stunning braided top and the mix of two creams in every slice. In Italy, crostata is pretty much everywhere, a beloved treat. But this version? It adds a twist with both a light and chocolate pasta frolla (shortcrust pastry). Inside, you'll find a thick layer of silky vanilla pastry cream right next to a rich chocolate version—so so creamy and smooth, with that touch of sweet flavor. Italians love a slice during their afternoon merenda. And the real fun? Watching who grabs which side first—the plain or the chocolate. The decorations on top—seriously good—not only look amazing but give the tart a tender finish. Different regions might swap in ricotta or jam, but this dual cream filling makes this chocolate tart recipe different on any table.

This dual chocolate tart is just perfect for when friends swing by or as a special weekend treat. Way more creative than your average tart, for real, with the combination of white and dark pastry cream setting it apart. Not just a basic layered crostata or the usual marble chocolate tart, it delivers both a classic and a new taste in one go. Sometimes, the shortcrust itself is super super buttery and crumbly, and the chocolate side? It adds a bittersweet edge. With each slice, you'll see that perfect line where the two fillings meet—almost too good to eat, but the golden crust and rich filling make it irresistible. The two-tone tart is great for birthday parties or as an after-dinner snack, especially for those who want a simple, homemade tart that feels special. Baking at home with this recipe lets you play around with flavors and decorations, creating a true Italian dessert that's a lot more fun. Whether you call it a chocolate tart recipe or a creative twist on crostata, it's the kind of easy dessert that brings people together for a moist, sweet bite every time. Pretty simple, right?

You might also like:

INGREDIENTS

Ingredients (for a 9-inch pan)
Type 00 flour 4 cups (500 g)
Butter 1.1 cups (250 g) - (cold from the fridge)
Eggs 3.9 oz (110 g) - (approximately 2 at room temperature)
Egg yolks 2 tbsp (30 g) - (about 2 at room temperature)
Sugar ¾ cup (180 g)
Unsweetened cocoa powder 2 tbsp (10 g)
for the creams
Whole milk 3 cups (740 g)
Egg yolks 8 tbsp (120 g) - (approximately 7)
Type 00 flour 0.7 cup (80 g)
Lemon peel 1
Sugar 1 ½ cup (300 g)
Dark chocolate 3.5 oz (100 g)

To prepare the shortcrust pastry and creams

To prepare the two-tone tart, first work on the shortcrust pastry. Cut the cold butter into cubes and place it in the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with a paddle attachment 1. Add the flour 2 and the sugar 3.

Turn on the stand mixer and work for about 2 minutes. Add the whole eggs 4 and the yolks 5. Turn on the machine again and work until you get a homogeneous and compact dough 6.

Transfer the dough to a surface, work briefly until compact, and divide it into two equal parts 7. Put one of the halves back in the mixer and add the cocoa powder 8. Work with the paddle attachment for a short time until you get a uniformly colored dough 9.

Place it back on the surface and compact it without overheating it with your hands 10. Then form two loaves, one cocoa, and one white, wrap them in plastic wrap 11, and let them rest in the refrigerator for at least 30 minutes. Meanwhile, prepare the custard. Combine the sugar and yolks in a saucepan 12.

Mix them with a spatula so that no air is incorporated, then add the flour 13. Mix again with the spatula 14. In another saucepan, pour the milk and grated lemon zest 15. Bring to a boil.

As soon as the milk starts to boil, pour a small amount over the egg mixture 16, mixing with a spatula. Then pour all the milk, mix with a spatula or whisk, and return to the heat. Cook 17 until the cream thickens and is almost boiling. Divide the cream into two equal parts, transferring it to two separate bowls 18.

Add the chopped chocolate to one of the bowls 19, mix well with a spatula or a whisk until it melts and you get a homogeneous mixture 20. Cover both creams with plastic wrap 21 and let cool in the refrigerator for about 1 hour.

To assemble and bake the two-tone tart

When the cream is cold, and the pastry has rested, you can assemble your tart. First, roll out the white pastry into a rectangle about 1/8 inch thick 22. Cut strips about 1/2 inch wide 23. Repeat the same operation for the cocoa pastry 34.

Place a sheet of parchment paper on a surface. Position a cocoa strip horizontally. Place a white one perpendicular to it 25, then place another cocoa one next to it 26. Continue in this way, alternating colors; for this step, you will need 8 white strips and 8 cocoa strips 27.

At this point, carefully lift all the cocoa strips 28 to place another white strip on the white ones 29. Then reposition the cocoa strips and lift the white strips this time 30.

Now place a cocoa strip horizontally 31, then flip the white strips back into position 32, and continue this way, alternating colors until you finish the weave 33 to create a square.

Using the ring of the 9-inch springform pan, cut the weave 34 and keep it in the fridge because it will firm up better 35; you'll need it later. Gather all the pastry scraps to make the marbled base of the tart 36.

Press well with your hands directly on the bottom to spread the dough both on the base 37 and the edges. Raise it as much as possible since it will have to contain the two creams. Trim the excess dough with a knife 38. First, pour the classic custard inside, level it with the back of a spoon 39, and refrigerate for 10 minutes.

Transfer the chocolate custard onto the classic one and level with the back of a spoon 40. Place the two-tone shortcrust lid you kept in the fridge over the cream by lifting and placing it very gently 41, and lightly press the edges to adhere to the pastry shell. Bake in a preheated static oven at 340°F for 45 minutes. Then increase the oven temperature to 355°F and continue baking for another 15 minutes. Take it out of the oven 42 and let it cool completely before serving your two-tone tart.

Storage

The two-tone tart can be stored in the refrigerator for 3 days.

Advice

To transfer the creams inside the tart more easily, we recommend using a piping bag.

In this case, we used flour instead of starch in the cream because it will have a second baking in the oven.

You can flavor the shortcrust pastry with vanilla and the cream with a pinch of cinnamon.

For the translation of some texts, artificial intelligence tools may have been used.